Knowledge Graph Inconsistencies

The Problem

Relationships between entities (users, teams, resources) stored inconsistently or incompletely, breaking multi-hop reasoning and access control logic.

Symptoms

• ❌ "Alice is in Engineering" + "Bob is in Engineering" but no team entity

• ❌ Relationships not bidirectional

• ❌ Entity resolution errors (multiple IDs for same entity)

• ❌ Broken transitive relationships

• ❌ Cannot query "who can access X?"

Real-World Example

Knowledge base facts:
→ Doc A: "Alice works on Project Phoenix"
→ Doc B: "Project Phoenix uses Database Prod-DB"
→ Doc C: "Bob manages Database Prod-DB"

Query: "Who can access Prod-DB?"

Expected reasoning:
→ Alice → Project Phoenix → Prod-DB ✓
→ Bob → manages → Prod-DB ✓

AI response: "Bob manages Prod-DB"
→ Missed: Alice's indirect access via Project Phoenix
→ Relationships not explicitly modeled

---

Deep Technical Analysis

Implicit vs Explicit Relationships

Text-Based (Implicit):

Current approach:
→ Facts embedded in text
→ "Alice is member of Engineering team"
→ LLM must infer relationships

Problems:
→ Inference unreliable
→ Multi-hop reasoning fails
→ Cannot query graph structure

Graph-Based (Explicit):

Knowledge graph:
→ Nodes: Alice, Engineering, Project Phoenix
→ Edges: 
  - Alice -[memberOf]-> Engineering
  - Engineering -[worksOn]-> Project Phoenix
  - Project Phoenix -[uses]-> Prod-DB

Graph query:
→ MATCH (u:User)-[:memberOf]->(t:Team)-[:worksOn]->(p:Project)-[:uses]->(d:Database {name: "Prod-DB"})
→ RETURN u

Explicit traversal finds Alice

Entity Resolution

Multiple Representations:

Same person, different references:
→ "Alice Smith"
→ "Alice S."
→ "A. Smith"
→ "[email protected]"
→ User ID: 12345

Without resolution:
→ Treated as 5 different entities
→ Relationships fragmented

Canonical Entities:

Entity resolution:
→ Create canonical: entity_id: "user_12345"
→ Map all variants:
  - "Alice Smith" → user_12345
  - "[email protected]" → user_12345

All relationships link to canonical ID

Relationship Types

Access Control Graph:

Relationship types:
→ memberOf: User → Team
→ hasAccess: Team → Resource
→ manages: User → Resource
→ inheritsFrom: Role → Role

Query: "Can Alice access X?"
→ Traverse: Alice -[memberOf]-> Team -[hasAccess]-> X
→ Or: Alice -[manages]-> X
→ Multiple paths possible

Temporal Relationships:

Relationships change over time:
→ "Alice was in Engineering (2022-2023)"
→ "Alice now in Sales (2024-present)"

Graph needs temporal dimension:
{
  from: "user_12345",
  to: "team_engineering",
  relationship: "memberOf",
  valid_from: "2022-01-01",
  valid_until: "2023-12-31"
}

Current query uses current relationships only

Hybrid RAG + KG

Combined Approach:

1. Vector retrieval: Find relevant chunks
2. Entity extraction: Identify entities in chunks
3. Graph expansion: Query KG for related entities
4. Enriched context: Chunks + graph facts

Example:
Query: "What does Alice work on?"
→ Vector: Retrieves "Alice's bio"
→ KG: Finds Alice's team, projects, permissions
→ Combined: Complete picture

---

How to Solve

Build explicit knowledge graph for entities and relationships + implement entity resolution (canonical IDs) + use typed relationships (memberOf, hasAccess, manages) + store bidirectional edges + implement graph traversal for multi-hop queries + combine vector search with graph expansion + maintain temporal validity of relationships + test access control queries against graph. See Knowledge Graphs.